|
|
|
|
| |
|
| |
| Community
Awareness Needed for Suicide Prevention
|
|
By
ASHFAQUE SWAPAN Special to
India-West
Ten years ago, Santosh Unni,
who was then 20 years old , was a very unhappy
young man. In March, 1996, his best friend had
died in a car accident. He went to Boston to
stay with his best friend's brother to support
each other, then came home in the fall of
1996.
On Dec. 2, 1996 his elder brother
Suresh had lunch with him. "We were supposed to
meet up at my uncle's house later that night,"
Suresh reminisced to India-West during an
interview. "I had to go to classes. My parents
were going to take him. We were all going to
meet at my uncle's house in Oak Park,
Ill."
But he didn't end up going with his
parents. When his parents returned they found
him in the basement, where he hanged himself.
The trauma of the event shook Suresh as
well. "For a while my life was not the best in
that I wasn't dealing with it the best way,"
Suresh recalls ruefully. He said he "turned a
lot to alcohol and drugs." He has seen a
counselor since then. "I got sober and have been
sober ever since."
The trauma of suicide
not only prematurely takes away a life, it also
leaves deep scars in the immediate family, and
researchers and activists say Asian American
communities, particularly the South Asian
community, need to get together and educate
themselves about it.
"To counter suicide
what we need is to develop a resiliency that we
don't seem to have to that degree," says Dr.
Aruna Jha, a clinical psychologist based in
Chicago who has launched the Asian American
Suicide Prevention Initiative. She said AASPI is
targeting the entire community.
"It's not
the one, two, three ten percent people who make
an attempt that are our target," she said. "Our
target is the entire community to say, 'Wake up!
Let's work together!' That's where we want to
head. We can't predict how long it's going to
take to get there."
Studies suggest that
various groups of South Asians may be vulnerable
to suicidal tendencies.
A study
sponsored by the American College Health
Association, measured depression, suicidal
ideation, and suicide attempts among 15,977
college students in the academic year
1999-2000. It found that Asian American students
in their sample were 1.5 times more likely to
report serious suicidal ideation as
compared to white students.
In a study
by Jha herself, she compared Asian Indian
college undergraduates to white students on
measures of depression, suicidal ideation and
stress using a web-based survey. While white
male youths are considered at higher risk of
suicide, in this study there were no differences
in suicidal ideation between white and Asian
Indian students. Also, women were as likely as
men to report suicidal ideation among Asian
Indians. Family stress was associated with
suicidal ideation in Asian Indians but not in
Whites. Thirty-seven percent of the Asian Indian
students reported clinically significant levels
of depression. Another group that may be
particularly vulnerable are South Asian women
who are victims of domestic violence. Studies
indicate South Asian women are more vulnerable
to domestic violence to begin with.
According to an NIH-funded study by
Boston University researcher Anita Raj,
"Intimate partner violence and intimate
partner violence-related homicide
disproportionately affect immigrant women. South
Asian women residing in the United States appear
to be at particularly high risk for intimate
partner violence, with 40 percent reporting
intimate partner violence in their current
relationship in a recent study. Other research
indicates that immigration-related social
isolation, often resulting from the absence of
both family in the United States and community
support for intimate partner violence victims,
and lack of awareness of intimate partner
violence services prevent battered South Asian
women from seeking help."
Sandeep
Bathala, an activist with the New York-based
activist group Sakhi, recently testified at a
N.Y. State Assembly hearing called by
Assemblyman Peter M. Rivera: "A study on South
Asian women in the diaspora indicates that high
rates of self-harm could arise due to a number
of precipitating factors. These factors can
range from social, political and economic
pressures to racism, poverty, language problems,
isolation, health issues and familial problems."
Bhatala put marital problems at the top
of the risk factors that can lead to suicidal
tendencies. " A few of the women in the study
reported that their husbands demanded them to
behave in a less Westernized fashion," she said
at the hearing. "Also, they reported that their
mothers-in-law interfered with the way they ran
their lives and marriages. Such factors, along
with arranged marriages, rejections of arranged
marriage proposals and other marital problems
place pressure on South Asian women, and thus
were reported as precipitating factors for
self-harm by the participants."
There
aren't specific numbers of suicide rates for
Asian Indians in the U.S., but Jha is working on
a study. "I have been funded at the state level
and I'm starting with the Illinois mortality
rates to break down suicide by ethnicity," Jha
said. "So we'll be in a better position to
answer that hopefully by the end of next
year."
However, the anecdotal evidence is
pretty grim. "Since 2004, when we established
(AASPI), in the Chicago area alone, I am aware
at least of six young people dying by suicide,
with the most recent one being just a couple of
months ago," she said.
Jha said there are
specific cultural factors that affect South
Asians, and the community needs to be educated
about it.
"We have some very unique
cultural scripts," she said. "Particularly in
reference to South Asians, we can identify
statements in our own mother tongues be it
Gujarati or Hindi or Tamil or what have you,
where at the drop of a hat you say things like
"Is se achchha main mar jaoo!" ('It's better for
me to die!') and it's very, very intriguing to
me that the context to statements like that are
affiliated both with intense joy as well as
intense sorrow. And parents don't hesitate
saying to young kids, 'I'd rather you die than
bring shame upon this family.'"
Cultural
sensitivity can be crucial for suicide survivors
to feel comfortable talking about it.
Savitha Viswanathan lost her elder
sister Srilatha in 2003 when she committed
suicide with an overdose of pills. She was 34.
Savitha and her sisters were raised in a fairly
liberal household, but after the suicide, when
she got to know Indian another family who had
lost a son, both went for a group session with
Jha.
"We drove to Chicago (from
Pennsylvania)," she told India-West. "That was
the first time my parents had ever done anything
like that. I don't know if my parents would have
seen her if she was not Indian. So I think it
made a big difference that my parents trusted
her on a level because the felt that she had
some awareness of where they were coming from
more so from someone local. I think that was
true. She did have a better understanding of
where they were coming from and she knew how to
speak to them in a way that was constructive
that didn't make them feel like she didn't
understand."
Jha said the community needs
to get together not just for the sake of those
with suicidal tendencies, or families who have
lost a loved one to suicide, but for the better
health of the entire community. "Suicide
prevention needs to become a movement of the
Asian American people in this country, which
implies that every Asian should be aware of our
inherent risk towards suicide, and of
organizations like AASPI and the willingness to
participate in activities that essentially
promote resiliency."
She said the entire
community has its work cut out. "It's not just
the family themselves, but it's a whole
community - we are all contributing towards
maintaining the problem by entrenching the
stigma," she said. "Then we can start
normalizing behavior patterns that are clearly
dysfunctional."
She is making an appeal
to survivors, i.e. family members who have lost
a loved one to suicide, to lead the path. She
quoted Elie Wiesel, a holocaust survivor, who
has said: "I happen to bear testimony for those
who have gone and for those who will come
tomorrow, so that the tragedy doesn't get
repeated again."
Jha added: "So
survivors, please come and join with us. We need
you. You have your pain, but maybe, you can
sublimate your pain and the knowledge of
somebody else will act in a timely fashion, and
somebody else's life could be saved by you
coming up and telling your story.
"When
the community will respond with compassion
instead of judging survivors they will come
forward and empower us, all
Indians."
Savitha Viswanathan added that
the gains could well go beyond helping suicide
survivors. "I think it'll lead to just not
people being more open talking about the issue
of suicide but these other issues also," she
said. "I mean, as a community we don't really
talk about lots of different things, you know
issues between the husband the wife, issues
between the children and parents. Just in
general you just don't see too many Indians
going to therapy. There are a lot of people who
want to talk about these things and they don't
have anywhere to go."
Interested readers
can find more information about AASPI by sending
an email to Aruna Jha at
arunajha@uic.edu |
|
|
|
| |
|
| |
| |
| | |
| |
| |
 | |
|
|
 | |